August 27, 2008

Will they fix the problems they created?

Filed under: Debate, Economics — Tim @ 12:44 am

For the Bob Barr activists that keep emailing me: stop por favor. Out of principle I don’t vote or donate to any campaign, not even Ron Paul — a person I generally agree with. Plus, I’ve never really liked Barr let alone his running mate.

And speaking of Ron Paul, I saw this picture over at his CfL site:

Ignoring whether or not you like Paul or libertarianism in general, I find the quote spot on.

While the collapse of the I-35 Minneapolis bridge comes to mind, the fact of the matter is the interstate highway system (which the federal government refuses to deregulate or privatize) has been a state of disrepair for years.

For instance, over the past decade, studies published by the American Society for Civil Engineers (ASCE) have estimated that it will cost $1.3-1.6 trillion to upgrade highways to a “good” condition.

Remember, these are the same highways in which 40,000 people die each year.

Yet as Walter Block recently noted in a podcast, if 40,000 people died on private highways, every human rights or consumer rights activist would be screaming at Congress to do something. But because the roads are already owned and maintained by the government, it is just seen as a fact of life. No one is ever fired or held accountable. And there is no incentive to upgrade or fix the roads because there is no outside competition.

In contrast, private companies have an incentive not to kill their consumers because customers will take their business elsewhere. Furthermore, entrepreneurs would be held accountable for negligence as they are in every other market-based industry.

But let’s ignore road socialism and look back at that quote.

According to the July report from Congressional Research Service the total costs for just the Iraq war is roughly $650 billion. If the troops were magically withdrawn today, the long-term costs for funding healthcare and welfare liabilities for the soldiers would reach more than $1 trillion or even $5 trillion.

If you include Afghanistan then add another $170 billion for a bill higher than Vietnam.

The human toll is at least 86,000 dead Iraqis from coalition-related violence and up to 1.2 million due to a combination of sectarian strife and civil war. And roughly 10,000 have died in Afghanistan.

So, the question remains: is either political party going to solve the quagmire they created? I am willing to bet all of the money I have earned this past year in Asia that neither party will solve these issues.

And that by next election cycle, government highways will still celebrate 40,000 fatalities annually and there will be a sizable presence in both Iraq and Afghanistan (think of Japan, Korea, Germany or Italy for continued US occupation).

Any takers?

2 Comments »

  1. The fact that so many people get hurt on government roads is proof that they’re too dangerous to leave in private hands!

    By the way, I happened to have just ordered The Enterprise of Law from the Mises Institute and it arrived last Friday. I can’t decide if I should read that or The Market For Liberty by Morris and Linda Tannehill first…

    Comment by John Petrie — August 27, 2008 @ 8:20 pm

  2. If Columbus hadn’t gotten lost. Would this land still belong to our ancestors? You know this really concerns me! United States Government! Knowing that the man sitting within the White House lied. Why do these two Senators act like he didn’t do it? Why are they allowing my ancestors ground (now called United States of America) to be messed with. Including the people that reside upon her. How can America be trusted when that Liar is still sitting within the White House? As a Native American. I can do something about this right? I mean we can make things RIGHT again? One could try? For there is a lot of wrong I see going on within Mother Earth an it is not very pretty at all! I really hate to say that! (oh I did already?lol) have a great day! It’s not really funny no more! I say NO MORE WAR! (ANY WHERE UPON MOTHER EARTH). WE ONLY HAVE ONE LIFE ONE PLANET AN LOVE SHOULD BE THEE ONLY WAY! (FOR EUGENICS HATE IS KILLING OUR PLANET AN MANY WALKS OF LIFE ALONG WITH MOTHER EARTHS CREATURES) IT REALLY MAKES ME WANT TO CRY. GEE I HOPE I AM NOT BORING YOU. ALRIGHTY THEN I THINK I SAID TO MUCH AS IT IS. HAVE A GREAT DAY!

    Comment by Earla Penn — September 4, 2008 @ 2:31 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML ( You can use these tags): <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .